Supporting Breastfeeding

La Leche League Canada

Being “Extravagantly Affectionate”

on February 10, 2014

by Teresa Pitman

When my children were babies, they spent most of their time in my arms (or in a wrap or carrier that kept them close to me). That’s where they liked to be, and I liked keeping them happy.

But I got lots of criticism. People told me I was spoiling them, that it wasn’t good for babies to be held and cuddled so much, that babies needed to be left to cry. It was at my La Leche League Canada Group meeting that I got support to follow my heart, though, and I kept right on carrying my babies.


A few years ago, a study ( was published that followed up on some earlier research. Those conducting the earlier research had observed mothers interacting with their eight-month-old babies. The majority (84.9%) were described as “warm” and normally affectionate. Another 8.9% were classified as “occasionally negative” towards their babies. Then there was the 1.5% described as “extravagantly affectionate.”

Now, remember, this initial study was done over 35 years ago, when warnings about spoiling were pretty rampant. I definitely would have been classified as extravagantly affectionate.

Joanna Maselko and her fellow researchers at Duke University tracked down these babies, now around 34 years old, and have them do a series of psychological tests to see if the affection they received from their mothers made a difference.

It did.

In all areas – anxiety, hostility, sensitivity to others, and physical symptoms related to psychological distress – those babies who had been given “extravagant affection” scored significantly better. There was little difference in results for those whose mothers were “warm” and those whose mothers were “occasionally negative.”

Maselko is quoted in a Globe and Mail article as saying “The takeaway for mothers is that they should follow ‘the more the better’ rule when it comes to doting on their children.” Her research suggests that “maybe you can’t be too affectionate.”


I agree. Let’s give our babies all the love that’s in our hearts, and stop worrying about this spoiling idea. Go ahead – be extravagantly affectionate. Your baby will appreciate it now, and will only benefit later.*


By Teresa Pitman, La Leche League Leader, Co-Author of The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding (8th edition) and Author of the new Preparing to Breastfeed: A Pregnant Woman’s Guide


If you need more information or have a breastfeeding problem or concern, you are strongly encouraged to talk directly to a La Leche League Leader.  In Canada, Leaders can be located by clicking  or  Internationally  


One response to “Being “Extravagantly Affectionate”

  1. Patricia says:

    Wisdom affirmed by research…thank you so much for sharing!

Your Comments are Welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: